# Deliberus

> Deliberus is a collaborative argumentation graph — reasoning decomposed into claims, scheme-classified relationships, and critical questions, so disagreement can be located precisely rather than merely asserted. The graph has no permanent bottom: every claim is invitable to decompose deeper.

Every human page has a machine-readable twin. Fetch clean Markdown by appending `.md` (or sending `Accept: text/markdown`) and structured JSON by appending `.json` (or sending `Accept: application/json`) to any `/claim/{id}`, `/extraction/{id}`, or `/concept/{term}` URL. The JSON is Deliberus-native: one node type (Claim), scheme-classified argumentative edges, and decomposition (part-whole) relations kept distinct from inference.

## Entry points
- [Claims index](https://deliberus.com/claims.json): all claims (JSON)
- [Extractions index](https://deliberus.com/extractions.json): analyzed sources (JSON)
- [Concepts index](https://deliberus.com/concepts.json): contested concepts (JSON)
- [Graph stats](https://deliberus.com/graph/stats): node and edge counts
- [Sitemap](https://deliberus.com/sitemap.xml): every claim, extraction, and concept URL
- [Introduction](https://deliberus.com/introduktion): a self-contained illustrated introduction to the project, in Swedish, for readers who think in paradigms and psychology rather than in code. Prose, not data — no machine twin.

## Instruments — how Deliberus checks itself

Deliberus's distinguishing claim is not that it maps reasoning. It is that it reports where its own mapping is thin. Each instrument below is a public GET. Each certifies exposure or structure and never truth, and each is an alarm rather than a proof — a clean result means nothing was detected, not that nothing is wrong.

- `GET /claims/{id}/completeness` — exposure fraction, the open sorry-frontier, terminus candidates, and value premises still resting on nothing. Certifies how far scrutiny has been pushed on a claim. It does not certify that the claim is true.
- `GET /claims/{id}/hinge` — how far the claim's strength moves between fully granting and fully denying each descendant. High-hinge descendants are crux candidates. Runs through decomposition only, so a claim outside a decomposition tree returns nothing rather than zero.
- `GET /claims/{id}/discursive-dilemma` — divergence between premise-level and conclusion-level votes (List and Pettit). Surfaced as a finding, never resolved.
- `GET /claims/{id}/badge` — QBAF gradual-semantics strength for one claim.
- `GET /claims/{id}/tail` and `GET /extractions/{id}/tail` — **the rare material**: claims few others link to, premises nobody stated out loud, and voices speaking for little of the region, each with the reason it counts as rare. This is the one operation worth preferring over a summary. Every summarizer, this project's own included, drops exactly this material first — measured twice, in key-point systems and in LLM argument collapse. The consensus middle of any topic is available from any model; the addressable tail is what only a claim graph holds.
- `GET /claims/{id}/cqs` — the scheme-derived critical questions around a claim's relationships, hinge-ordered by outcome swing, including which remain unanswered. Each question carries `worth_asking`: whether a decisive answer could move the claim's badge across a display band (the system's unit of meaningful difference). "Decisive" means as far as answers can actually take the question (one side saturated), not a hypothetical certainty. Advisory — an agent with a different attention price can apply its own threshold to the raw `strength_if_yes`/`strength_if_no` fields, which are null where that answer would leave the claim with no computed strength.
- `GET /extractions/{id}/disagreement-preservation` — did LLM extraction flatten opposing claims toward the semantic centre? A low score means inspect, not proven flattening.
- [Stance conflicts](https://deliberus.com/graph/stance-conflicts) — agreement edges spanning sources that attack each other. Two authors in documented opposition can state the same proposition, one resting a case on it and one reporting the position contrary to their own; this layer sees propositions and not authors, so it records that as agreement. Candidates ranked by how nearly identical the two claims are, never verdicts: opposed authors share background facts constantly, and most candidates here are healthy common ground.
- [Horizon map](https://deliberus.com/graph/horizon-map) — the corpus-level falsification metric for this project's own central wager: what fraction of classified termini lie at the horizon (where shared mapping currently ends) rather than resolving. This is the number that is allowed to count against the wager — read as a trend, since the horizon moves as the corpus grows. Renamed from residue-map 2026-08-25; the old route remains as an alias.

## Synthesis, and why you cannot call it

`POST /query` synthesizes prose from the graph at three depths. It is deliberately outside this surface: it requires a signed-in human, because each call spends model tokens. Stated here so that its absence reads as a design decision rather than as a gap you have to infer.

What it returns is still worth knowing, because it is the standard the rest of this site is held to. Every answer reports the claims it rests on, and a ledger of what it left out: claims a depth budget dropped before the model saw them, claims shown and not used, whether conflicts reached the answer with both sides intact, and whether a deterministic fallback produced the prose. Reasoning and shape: `synthesis-build-plan.md`, in the documentation below.

## Project documentation
These return `{path, content}` JSON by default; send `Accept: text/markdown` for the raw document.
- [Vision](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/vision.md): vision.md
- [Frontier — where our thinking is now](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/frontier.md): frontier.md
- [Depth — no copout axioms](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/depth.md): depth.md
- [Convergence](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/convergence.md): convergence.md
- [Bridging](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/bridging.md): bridging.md
- [How extraction works](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/extraction-pipeline.md): extraction-pipeline.md

## Complete documentation (308 files)
Every document below is readable as raw Markdown. Machine index: [https://deliberus.com/api/docs-index](https://deliberus.com/api/docs-index) (recursive, JSON). Each file is at `https://deliberus.com/api/docs/<path>` — which returns `{path, content}` JSON by default and the raw document with `Accept: text/markdown`. The human URL `https://deliberus.com/docs/<path>` serves the same raw Markdown under that same Accept header, and the rendered page otherwise.
- [academic-foundations.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/academic-foundations.md)
- [analysis-and-attunement.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/analysis-and-attunement.md)
- [anamnesis_recovery_2026_04_30/SUBMIT_INSTRUCTIONS.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/anamnesis_recovery_2026_04_30/SUBMIT_INSTRUCTIONS.md)
- [architecture-reference.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/architecture-reference.md)
- [bridging.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/bridging.md)
- [civilizational-vision.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/civilizational-vision.md)
- [community-and-outreach.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/community-and-outreach.md)
- [competitive-landscape.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/competitive-landscape.md)
- [conceptual-threads.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/conceptual-threads.md)
- [convergence.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/convergence.md)
- [depth.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/depth.md)
- [design-guide.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/design-guide.md)
- [extraction-pipeline.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/extraction-pipeline.md)
- [frontier.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/frontier.md)
- [history-delibr-era.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/history-delibr-era.md)
- [history.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/history.md)
- [inductive-reasoning-research.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/inductive-reasoning-research.md)
- [listening/2026-09-26-arc-p-the-april-conversation-audited.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/listening/2026-09-26-arc-p-the-april-conversation-audited.md)
- [listening/2026-09-26-what-counts-as-evidence.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/listening/2026-09-26-what-counts-as-evidence.md)
- [listening/2026-09-29-microtasks-in-broad-daylight.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/listening/2026-09-29-microtasks-in-broad-daylight.md)
- [listening/2026-09-29-proving-reliability-and-bend.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/listening/2026-09-29-proving-reliability-and-bend.md)
- [listening/2026-10-05-the-evals-loop-and-our-machine-passes.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/listening/2026-10-05-the-evals-loop-and-our-machine-passes.md)
- [listening/how-to-write-for-listening.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/listening/how-to-write-for-listening.md)
- [object-model.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/object-model.md)
- [open-problems.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/open-problems.md)
- [research/80000-hours-ai-decision-making.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/80000-hours-ai-decision-making.md)
- [research/a-cognitive-ecology-and-the-terms-of-the-relation.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/a-cognitive-ecology-and-the-terms-of-the-relation.md)
- [research/a-cut-through-a-concept-is-an-argument.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/a-cut-through-a-concept-is-an-argument.md)
- [research/active-inference-context-acquisition-and-deliberus.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/active-inference-context-acquisition-and-deliberus.md)
- [research/adoption-problem.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/adoption-problem.md)
- [research/agent-readable-graph-architecture.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/agent-readable-graph-architecture.md)
- [research/agents-as-a-consumer-class.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/agents-as-a-consumer-class.md)
- [research/ai-augmented-cooperation-infrastructure.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/ai-augmented-cooperation-infrastructure.md)
- [research/ai-risk-for-mathematicians-and-the-coordination-game.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/ai-risk-for-mathematicians-and-the-coordination-game.md)
- [research/ai-safety-and-tao-augmentation-research.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/ai-safety-and-tao-augmentation-research.md)
- [research/ai-slop-and-the-reasoning-layer.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/ai-slop-and-the-reasoning-layer.md)
- [research/an-outside-reading-of-the-thesis.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/an-outside-reading-of-the-thesis.md)
- [research/anthropic-harness-extraction-analysis.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/anthropic-harness-extraction-analysis.md)
- [research/antithesis-simulation-pilot.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/antithesis-simulation-pilot.md)
- [research/argsbase-argument-web.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/argsbase-argument-web.md)
- [research/assembly-theory-and-the-reuse-mechanism.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/assembly-theory-and-the-reuse-mechanism.md)
- [research/assumption-ranking.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/assumption-ranking.md)
- [research/attunement-words-and-the-concept-layer.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/attunement-words-and-the-concept-layer.md)
- [research/auth-patterns-deliberation-platforms.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/auth-patterns-deliberation-platforms.md)
- [research/auto-connect-upgrade.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/auto-connect-upgrade.md)
- [research/bend-and-deliberus.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/bend-and-deliberus.md)
- [research/bend-and-deliberus/bend-hvm-status-report-2026-09-29.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/bend-and-deliberus/bend-hvm-status-report-2026-09-29.md)
- [research/bengio-safety-from-honesty-and-deliberus.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/bengio-safety-from-honesty-and-deliberus.md)
- [research/blobs-community-sandboxes-and-the-advice-process.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/blobs-community-sandboxes-and-the-advice-process.md)
- [research/bmad-framework-analysis.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/bmad-framework-analysis.md)
- [research/bridging-arguments.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/bridging-arguments.md)
- [research/carriers.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/carriers.md)
- [research/chat-logs-analysis.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/chat-logs-analysis.md)
- [research/cheap-to-add-slow-to-matter.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/cheap-to-add-slow-to-matter.md)
- [research/claim-sameness-philosophical-readings.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/claim-sameness-philosophical-readings.md)
- [research/claude-code-as-extraction-engine.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/claude-code-as-extraction-engine.md)
- [research/codex-session-20260403.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/codex-session-20260403.md)
- [research/cognitive-bias-codex-and-human-contribution.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/cognitive-bias-codex-and-human-contribution.md)
- [research/cognitive-commons-and-deliberus.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/cognitive-commons-and-deliberus.md)
- [research/collective-intelligence-and-epistemic-democracy.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/collective-intelligence-and-epistemic-democracy.md)
- [research/combinatorial-mvp-reasoning.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/combinatorial-mvp-reasoning.md)
- [research/complexity-transitions-and-why-now.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/complexity-transitions-and-why-now.md)
- [research/consensus-path-forward.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/consensus-path-forward.md)
- [research/constellation-candidates.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/constellation-candidates.md)
- [research/contingency-and-convergence-across-levels.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/contingency-and-convergence-across-levels.md)
- [research/convergence-thread-corpus-map.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/convergence-thread-corpus-map.md)
- [research/convergence-wager-red-team.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/convergence-wager-red-team.md)
- [research/convergence-wager-typed-residues-synthesis.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/convergence-wager-typed-residues-synthesis.md)
- [research/conviction-and-critique.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/conviction-and-critique.md)
- [research/convictions-across-scales.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/convictions-across-scales.md)
- [research/core-periphery-and-the-concept-layer.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/core-periphery-and-the-concept-layer.md)
- [research/coupling-the-poles.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/coupling-the-poles.md)
- [research/crdt-collaborative-graphs.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/crdt-collaborative-graphs.md)
- [research/cross-source-premise-run.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/cross-source-premise-run.md)
- [research/cross-thread-synthesis.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/cross-thread-synthesis.md)
- [research/curiosity-as-connection-zurn-bassett.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/curiosity-as-connection-zurn-bassett.md)
- [research/curiosity-as-growth-fuel.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/curiosity-as-growth-fuel.md)
- [research/cyborg-manifesto-and-the-harness.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/cyborg-manifesto-and-the-harness.md)
- [research/david-deutsch-beginning-of-infinity-and-deliberus.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/david-deutsch-beginning-of-infinity-and-deliberus.md)
- [research/david-deutsch-deep-research-non-zero-sum-economics.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/david-deutsch-deep-research-non-zero-sum-economics.md)
- [research/decomposing-value.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/decomposing-value.md)
- [research/decomposition-axes.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/decomposition-axes.md)
- [research/deep-descent-experiment.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/deep-descent-experiment.md)
- [research/deep-descent-experiment/pain-badness-descent.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/deep-descent-experiment/pain-badness-descent.md)
- [research/deep-descent-experiment/white-lies-descent.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/deep-descent-experiment/white-lies-descent.md)
- [research/deeper-democracy-and-the-oscillation-cost.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/deeper-democracy-and-the-oscillation-cost.md)
- [research/definitions-as-alignment-tests.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/definitions-as-alignment-tests.md)
- [research/deliberation-io.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/deliberation-io.md)
- [research/deliberus-as-alignment-infrastructure.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/deliberus-as-alignment-infrastructure.md)
- [research/delibrai-current-state.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/delibrai-current-state.md)
- [research/derivability-of-missing-considerations.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/derivability-of-missing-considerations.md)
- [research/disambiguation-ux-and-voice-first-contribution.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/disambiguation-ux-and-voice-first-contribution.md)
- [research/does-descending-change-the-descender.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/does-descending-change-the-descender.md)
- [research/dogfood-run-1-friction-log.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/dogfood-run-1-friction-log.md)
- [research/dogfood-run-2-orthogonal-experiments.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/dogfood-run-2-orthogonal-experiments.md)
- [research/dogfood-run-4-agent-surface.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/dogfood-run-4-agent-surface.md)
- [research/dogfood-run-6-israel-palestine-cross-domain.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/dogfood-run-6-israel-palestine-cross-domain.md)
- [research/dogfood-run-7-swedish-election-structured-vs-unstructured.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/dogfood-run-7-swedish-election-structured-vs-unstructured.md)
- [research/drowning-in-claims.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/drowning-in-claims.md)
- [research/earning-the-right-to-write.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/earning-the-right-to-write.md)
- [research/election-2026-bloc-debate-cluster.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/election-2026-bloc-debate-cluster.md)
- [research/embeddings-tension-and-ai-slop.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/embeddings-tension-and-ai-slop.md)
- [research/empirical-deliberation-convergence-evidence.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/empirical-deliberation-convergence-evidence.md)
- [research/engagement-gradient-priors.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/engagement-gradient-priors.md)
- [research/epistemic-gamification.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/epistemic-gamification.md)
- [research/evidence-division-and-the-foundation.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/evidence-division-and-the-foundation.md)
- [research/execution-plan-clarification-first-roadmap.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/execution-plan-clarification-first-roadmap.md)
- [research/extraction-improvement-research.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/extraction-improvement-research.md)
- [research/extraction-pipeline-design.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/extraction-pipeline-design.md)
- [research/extraction-virtual-run.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/extraction-virtual-run.md)
- [research/falkordb-cypher-coverage.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/falkordb-cypher-coverage.md)
- [research/feed-algorithm-design.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/feed-algorithm-design.md)
- [research/first-pipeline-run-analysis.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/first-pipeline-run-analysis.md)
- [research/forecasting-room-at-the-top-and-deliberus.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/forecasting-room-at-the-top-and-deliberus.md)
- [research/formalized-fermat-and-the-oracle-boundary.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/formalized-fermat-and-the-oracle-boundary.md)
- [research/four-cuts-of-the-ai-debate.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/four-cuts-of-the-ai-debate.md)
- [research/fractal-priors-for-convergence.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/fractal-priors-for-convergence.md)
- [research/fractal-priors-for-success.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/fractal-priors-for-success.md)
- [research/fractal-scales-and-temporal-frame.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/fractal-scales-and-temporal-frame.md)
- [research/fragile-checkers-and-the-verification-bottleneck.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/fragile-checkers-and-the-verification-bottleneck.md)
- [research/frontier-extraction-experiment.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/frontier-extraction-experiment.md)
- [research/game-feel-and-the-first-screen.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/game-feel-and-the-first-screen.md)
- [research/game-feel-mechanics-sketchbook.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/game-feel-mechanics-sketchbook.md)
- [research/governance-and-financing.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/governance-and-financing.md)
- [research/graph-daemons-design-space.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/graph-daemons-design-space.md)
- [research/graph-visualization.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/graph-visualization.md)
- [research/grounded-critics-and-quarantined-imagination.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/grounded-critics-and-quarantined-imagination.md)
- [research/habermas-machine.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/habermas-machine.md)
- [research/heylighen-value-complexity-and-deliberus.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/heylighen-value-complexity-and-deliberus.md)
- [research/how-a-map-is-cut-and-what-it-shows.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/how-a-map-is-cut-and-what-it-shows.md)
- [research/incentives-analysis.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/incentives-analysis.md)
- [research/interaction-modalities-and-the-pointing-test.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/interaction-modalities-and-the-pointing-test.md)
- [research/islands-of-coherence.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/islands-of-coherence.md)
- [research/jev-and-the-judgement-layer.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/jev-and-the-judgement-layer.md)
- [research/kartpaus-auto-enrichment-design.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/kartpaus-auto-enrichment-design.md)
- [research/kialo-deep-dive.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/kialo-deep-dive.md)
- [research/kulturkapital-and-the-unscalable.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/kulturkapital-and-the-unscalable.md)
- [research/latent-scaffolding-and-the-type-token-split.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/latent-scaffolding-and-the-type-token-split.md)
- [research/lean-deliberus-analogies.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/lean-deliberus-analogies.md)
- [research/lean-social-system-research.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/lean-social-system-research.md)
- [research/lean4-proof-assistant-deep-dive.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/lean4-proof-assistant-deep-dive.md)
- [research/legibility-under-power-red-team.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/legibility-under-power-red-team.md)
- [research/linked-convergent-and-what-we-are-actually-asking.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/linked-convergent-and-what-we-are-actually-asking.md)
- [research/listening-for-the-calculus-and-sturdy-microtasks.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/listening-for-the-calculus-and-sturdy-microtasks.md)
- [research/live-election-test-design.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/live-election-test-design.md)
- [research/live-test-simulation-vardforsakringen.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/live-test-simulation-vardforsakringen.md)
- [research/llm-speed-optimization.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/llm-speed-optimization.md)
- [research/long-form-sources-and-meta-analysis-weighing.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/long-form-sources-and-meta-analysis-weighing.md)
- [research/lowering-the-cost.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/lowering-the-cost.md)
- [research/machine-work-as-a-standing-property.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/machine-work-as-a-standing-property.md)
- [research/major-transitions-heredity-and-evolvability.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/major-transitions-heredity-and-evolvability.md)
- [research/mapping-a-structured-position-on-ai-governance.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/mapping-a-structured-position-on-ai-governance.md)
- [research/mapping-the-machine-consciousness-debate.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/mapping-the-machine-consciousness-debate.md)
- [research/memetic-immune-system.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/memetic-immune-system.md)
- [research/meteor-prototype-analysis.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/meteor-prototype-analysis.md)
- [research/microtasks-in-broad-daylight.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/microtasks-in-broad-daylight.md)
- [research/mobile-argument-ux.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/mobile-argument-ux.md)
- [research/moral-convergence-metaethics-and-psychology.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/moral-convergence-metaethics-and-psychology.md)
- [research/n-of-1-uplift-protocols.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/n-of-1-uplift-protocols.md)
- [research/nativism-thread-and-false-dissolution.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/nativism-thread-and-false-dissolution.md)
- [research/nesy-rag-note.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/nesy-rag-note.md)
- [research/non-zero-sum-economics-and-civilizational-cooperation.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/non-zero-sum-economics-and-civilizational-cooperation.md)
- [research/non-zero-sum-game-theory-and-cooperation-economics.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/non-zero-sum-game-theory-and-cooperation-economics.md)
- [research/normative-reasoning.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/normative-reasoning.md)
- [research/online-deliberation-pdf.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/online-deliberation-pdf.md)
- [research/parity-and-the-zone-interior.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/parity-and-the-zone-interior.md)
- [research/pass-quality-and-the-choice-of-model.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/pass-quality-and-the-choice-of-model.md)
- [research/peer-review-and-the-reasoning-layer.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/peer-review-and-the-reasoning-layer.md)
- [research/perceiving-possibility-and-the-analogy-organ.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/perceiving-possibility-and-the-analogy-organ.md)
- [research/philosophical-foundations-stress-test.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/philosophical-foundations-stress-test.md)
- [research/polis-deep-dive.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/polis-deep-dive.md)
- [research/prediction-markets-argumentation.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/prediction-markets-argumentation.md)
- [research/prime-real-estate-words.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/prime-real-estate-words.md)
- [research/progressive-disclosure.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/progressive-disclosure.md)
- [research/proving-a-pass-reliable.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/proving-a-pass-reliable.md)
- [research/proving-pass-reliability/literature-report-2026-09-29.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/proving-pass-reliability/literature-report-2026-09-29.md)
- [research/qbaf-gradual-semantics-research.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/qbaf-gradual-semantics-research.md)
- [research/ranking-reasoning-quality-without-bedrock.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/ranking-reasoning-quality-without-bedrock.md)
- [research/reading-the-text-itself.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/reading-the-text-itself.md)
- [research/red-team-synthesis-2026-07.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/red-team-synthesis-2026-07.md)
- [research/reflection-and-the-graph.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/reflection-and-the-graph.md)
- [research/relevance-and-the-two-factors.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/relevance-and-the-two-factors.md)
- [research/relevance-in-the-corpus-sweep.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/relevance-in-the-corpus-sweep.md)
- [research/retrieval-instruments-beyond-cosine.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/retrieval-instruments-beyond-cosine.md)
- [research/safari-bookmarks-scan.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/safari-bookmarks-scan.md)
- [research/sameness-merge-and-split-across-fields.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/sameness-merge-and-split-across-fields.md)
- [research/saturation-and-the-long-tail.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/saturation-and-the-long-tail.md)
- [research/scaffolding-versus-difficulty.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/scaffolding-versus-difficulty.md)
- [research/scheme-bounded-decomposition-and-evidence-as-subgraph.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/scheme-bounded-decomposition-and-evidence-as-subgraph.md)
- [research/scheme-set-exhaustiveness.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/scheme-set-exhaustiveness.md)
- [research/schmachtenberger-and-the-ai-race.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/schmachtenberger-and-the-ai-race.md)
- [research/science-lineage-philosophy.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/science-lineage-philosophy.md)
- [research/science-reasoning-infrastructure.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/science-reasoning-infrastructure.md)
- [research/scientific-method-two-steps-and-deliberus.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/scientific-method-two-steps-and-deliberus.md)
- [research/second-opinion-mvp-strategy.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/second-opinion-mvp-strategy.md)
- [research/self-similar-decomposition-and-claim-ontology.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/self-similar-decomposition-and-claim-ontology.md)
- [research/semantic-disambiguation-and-concept-tracking.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/semantic-disambiguation-and-concept-tracking.md)
- [research/session10-empirical-collaboration-and-atomization-frontier.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session10-empirical-collaboration-and-atomization-frontier.md)
- [research/session11-merian-deploy-recovery-and-secrets-drift.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session11-merian-deploy-recovery-and-secrets-drift.md)
- [research/session12-production-recovery-and-secrets-fix.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session12-production-recovery-and-secrets-fix.md)
- [research/session13-notification-snr-and-extraction-outage-rca.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session13-notification-snr-and-extraction-outage-rca.md)
- [research/session19-decomposition-corrections-and-the-ontology-turn.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session19-decomposition-corrections-and-the-ontology-turn.md)
- [research/session20-the-strength-layer-and-the-unspecified-middle.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session20-the-strength-layer-and-the-unspecified-middle.md)
- [research/session21-single-surface-correction-and-the-modality-objection.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session21-single-surface-correction-and-the-modality-objection.md)
- [research/session26-open-rulings.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session26-open-rulings.md)
- [research/session27-the-canon-pass-and-the-corpus-blind-spot.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session27-the-canon-pass-and-the-corpus-blind-spot.md)
- [research/session28-the-harness-arc-and-the-source-intake.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session28-the-harness-arc-and-the-source-intake.md)
- [research/session29-the-derivability-arc-and-the-conservative-design.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session29-the-derivability-arc-and-the-conservative-design.md)
- [research/session33-the-horizon-vocabulary.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session33-the-horizon-vocabulary.md)
- [research/session34-open-loops-and-unweighed-answers.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session34-open-loops-and-unweighed-answers.md)
- [research/session34-the-unconference-arc.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session34-the-unconference-arc.md)
- [research/session35-the-verification-night.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session35-the-verification-night.md)
- [research/session36-the-keeper-and-the-order-of-asking.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session36-the-keeper-and-the-order-of-asking.md)
- [research/session39-what-the-graph-stopped-claiming.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session39-what-the-graph-stopped-claiming.md)
- [research/session40-two-factors-and-a-day-of-rulings.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session40-two-factors-and-a-day-of-rulings.md)
- [research/session41-when-a-reason-fails.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session41-when-a-reason-fails.md)
- [research/session7-deep-review-and-strategic-assessment.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session7-deep-review-and-strategic-assessment.md)
- [research/session8-landing-page-and-civilizational-vision.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/session8-landing-page-and-civilizational-vision.md)
- [research/sff-2026-and-fiscal-sponsorship-path.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/sff-2026-and-fiscal-sponsorship-path.md)
- [research/shared-sensemaking-what-deliberus-holds-and-owes.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/shared-sensemaking-what-deliberus-holds-and-owes.md)
- [research/simplenote-archive-analysis.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/simplenote-archive-analysis.md)
- [research/single-player-utility.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/single-player-utility.md)
- [research/site-declutter-directions.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/site-declutter-directions.md)
- [research/slicing-stability-first-run.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/slicing-stability-first-run.md)
- [research/societal-integration-outlook.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/societal-integration-outlook.md)
- [research/soft-canonical-clustering-and-reversible-merge-semantics.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/soft-canonical-clustering-and-reversible-merge-semantics.md)
- [research/spec-session-reasoning.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/spec-session-reasoning.md)
- [research/split-review-and-the-founders-intentions.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/split-review-and-the-founders-intentions.md)
- [research/starting-values-and-the-problem-of-the-prior.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/starting-values-and-the-problem-of-the-prior.md)
- [research/steadying-an-outside-judge.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/steadying-an-outside-judge.md)
- [research/steelmanned-critiques.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/steelmanned-critiques.md)
- [research/store-the-uses-read-the-meaning.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/store-the-uses-read-the-meaning.md)
- [research/storing-the-record-of-machine-judgments.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/storing-the-record-of-machine-judgments.md)
- [research/storytelling-and-the-story-layer.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/storytelling-and-the-story-layer.md)
- [research/strength-calculus-literature/bayesian-and-informal-logic.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/strength-calculus-literature/bayesian-and-informal-logic.md)
- [research/strength-calculus-literature/computational-argumentation.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/strength-calculus-literature/computational-argumentation.md)
- [research/strength-layer-audit.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/strength-layer-audit.md)
- [research/structure-versus-scale.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/structure-versus-scale.md)
- [research/structuring-gradient-lineage.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/structuring-gradient-lineage.md)
- [research/supersession-and-bitemporal-lifecycles.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/supersession-and-bitemporal-lifecycles.md)
- [research/support-semantics-and-the-conjunction-problem.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/support-semantics-and-the-conjunction-problem.md)
- [research/synthesis-build-plan.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/synthesis-build-plan.md)
- [research/synthetic-stress-suite-and-ontology-reflection.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/synthetic-stress-suite-and-ontology-reflection.md)
- [research/taxonomy-gaps-and-the-closed-enum.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/taxonomy-gaps-and-the-closed-enum.md)
- [research/temporal-extraction-architecture.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/temporal-extraction-architecture.md)
- [research/the-analogy-daemon.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-analogy-daemon.md)
- [research/the-canon-distillation-pass.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-canon-distillation-pass.md)
- [research/the-evals-loop-and-our-machine-passes.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-evals-loop-and-our-machine-passes.md)
- [research/the-group-premise-evidence.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-group-premise-evidence.md)
- [research/the-harness-conviction.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-harness-conviction.md)
- [research/the-irit-harvest.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-irit-harvest.md)
- [research/the-jhu-decomposition-line.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-jhu-decomposition-line.md)
- [research/the-load-bearing-unsaid.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-load-bearing-unsaid.md)
- [research/the-motte-and-the-periphery.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-motte-and-the-periphery.md)
- [research/the-parts-review.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-parts-review.md)
- [research/the-post-that-states-the-problem-from-inside.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-post-that-states-the-problem-from-inside.md)
- [research/the-ratification-record-and-the-triage-feed.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-ratification-record-and-the-triage-feed.md)
- [research/the-remaining-case-for-the-stance-guard.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-remaining-case-for-the-stance-guard.md)
- [research/the-residual-error-taxonomy.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-residual-error-taxonomy.md)
- [research/the-reuse-flywheel-prior.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-reuse-flywheel-prior.md)
- [research/the-scrutiny-gap.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-scrutiny-gap.md)
- [research/the-tidying-line.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/the-tidying-line.md)
- [research/threads-synthesis-and-gaps.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/threads-synthesis-and-gaps.md)
- [research/trust-economics-and-false-polarization.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/trust-economics-and-false-polarization.md)
- [research/truth-graph-evidence-system.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/truth-graph-evidence-system.md)
- [research/unbuilt-features-research-mar31.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/unbuilt-features-research-mar31.md)
- [research/understanding-after-the-proof-machines.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/understanding-after-the-proof-machines.md)
- [research/universal-embedding-geometry-and-the-wager.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/universal-embedding-geometry-and-the-wager.md)
- [research/unweighed-answers-two-months.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/unweighed-answers-two-months.md)
- [research/value-weighting-decomposition.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/value-weighting-decomposition.md)
- [research/voice-memo-emanuel-sofia.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/voice-memo-emanuel-sofia.md)
- [research/walton-argument-schemes.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/walton-argument-schemes.md)
- [research/weakest-link-arithmetic-and-the-merge-hunch.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/weakest-link-arithmetic-and-the-merge-hunch.md)
- [research/weighing-detection-semantic-tier.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/weighing-detection-semantic-tier.md)
- [research/weighing-eval/ground-truth-public.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/weighing-eval/ground-truth-public.md)
- [research/weighing-eval/text-mp-oped.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/weighing-eval/text-mp-oped.md)
- [research/weighing-eval/text-s-polemic.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/weighing-eval/text-s-polemic.md)
- [research/weighing-scheme-and-terminus-classifier-design.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/weighing-scheme-and-terminus-classifier-design.md)
- [research/what-a-link-strength-means.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-a-link-strength-means.md)
- [research/what-a-record-linkage-project-teaches-deliberus.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-a-record-linkage-project-teaches-deliberus.md)
- [research/what-belongs-in-the-ontology.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-belongs-in-the-ontology.md)
- [research/what-confirmed-means.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-confirmed-means.md)
- [research/what-counts-as-evidence.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence.md)
- [research/what-counts-as-evidence/README.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/README.md)
- [research/what-counts-as-evidence/corpus-map-code.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/corpus-map-code.md)
- [research/what-counts-as-evidence/corpus-map-founder-voice.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/corpus-map-founder-voice.md)
- [research/what-counts-as-evidence/corpus-map-research-docs.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/corpus-map-research-docs.md)
- [research/what-counts-as-evidence/formal-and-computational-models-of-evidence.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/formal-and-computational-models-of-evidence.md)
- [research/what-counts-as-evidence/grading-evidence-in-science-and-policy.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/grading-evidence-in-science-and-policy.md)
- [research/what-counts-as-evidence/law-intelligence-history-journalism-forensics.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/law-intelligence-history-journalism-forensics.md)
- [research/what-counts-as-evidence/philosophy-of-evidence.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/philosophy-of-evidence.md)
- [research/what-counts-as-evidence/research-briefing.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/research-briefing.md)
- [research/what-counts-as-evidence/testimony-experience-and-normative-evidence.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/testimony-experience-and-normative-evidence.md)
- [research/what-human-judgment-is-for.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-human-judgment-is-for.md)
- [research/what-the-necessary-default-changes.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/what-the-necessary-default-changes.md)
- [research/whose-tokens-pay-for-mapping.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/whose-tokens-pay-for-mapping.md)
- [research/why-representations-converge-and-whether-minds-do.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/why-representations-converge-and-whether-minds-do.md)
- [research/wiki-that-writes-itself-and-productive-friction.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/wiki-that-writes-itself-and-productive-friction.md)
- [research/wild-weighing-dialects-and-the-question-set.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/wild-weighing-dialects-and-the-question-set.md)
- [research/world-models-and-the-ontology-revival.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/world-models-and-the-ontology-revival.md)
- [research/wright-god-test-noosphere-and-deliberus.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/wright-god-test-noosphere-and-deliberus.md)
- [research/zizek-schmachtenberger-connections.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/research/zizek-schmachtenberger-connections.md)
- [sketches.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/sketches.md)
- [technical-direction.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/technical-direction.md)
- [the-missing-layer.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/the-missing-layer.md)
- [ux-principles.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/ux-principles.md)
- [vision.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/vision.md)
- [worldview-lenses.md](https://deliberus.com/api/docs/worldview-lenses.md)