{"path":"research/corpus-graph/areas.md","content":"# Corpus areas for Ruby's talks\n\n*Made 2026-11-08 by `scripts/corpus_areas.py`, his ask of 2026-11-08: areas of at most 300,000 tokens, built from the corpus graph. Ward clustering of note vectors (mean chunk embedding from mannaminne, centred, pulled 0.3 toward joined notes), its tree cut until each branch holds at most 300000 tokens; ledger rows follow their home note. Names are a session's reading, not a ruling.*\n\nCosts on Gemini 3.6 Flash in kronor: **load** creates the cache, **an hour** is the rent while it exists, **an exchange** reads it once. A two-hour talk with 30 exchanges is load + 2 hours + 30 exchanges. Prices double on 2027-01-01.\n\n| Area | Tokens | Load | An hour | An exchange | Two-hour talk, now | From January | Wheel themes |\n|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---|\n| Scales, transitions and judgment | 290,086 | 2.1 | 1.4 | 0.21 | 11 | 23 | Ontology 45, Studies 33, Convergence 26, Human checks 26 |\n| Adoption, democracy and strategy | 267,585 | 2.0 | 1.3 | 0.20 | 11 | 21 | Studies 38, Strategy 31, Convergence 12, Pipeline 11 |\n| Science, proof and the AI race | 274,194 | 2.0 | 1.4 | 0.20 | 11 | 22 | Human checks 20, Strategy 13, Ontology 12, Pipeline 11 |\n| Priors, cases and how reasons add | 270,016 | 2.0 | 1.3 | 0.20 | 11 | 21 | Studies 12, Ontology 9, Relevance 6, Parts 6 |\n| What counts as evidence | 229,508 | 1.7 | 1.1 | 0.17 | 9 | 18 | Parts 7, Studies 7, Human checks 3, Convergence 3 |\n| The project reading itself | 238,159 | 1.8 | 1.2 | 0.18 | 10 | 19 | Human checks 31, Pipeline 5, Parts 4, Strategy 3 |\n| Maps, the graph and the early group | 214,938 | 1.6 | 1.1 | 0.16 | 9 | 17 | Ontology 9, Strategy 8, Linking 8, Parts 5 |\n| Strength and relevance | 215,515 | 1.6 | 1.1 | 0.16 | 9 | 17 | Parts 21, Relevance 20, Ontology 5, Linking 2 |\n| Values and convergence | 209,172 | 1.6 | 1.0 | 0.15 | 8 | 17 | Studies 43, Ontology 29, Convergence 20, Pipeline 4 |\n| Rules, analogy and minds | 200,431 | 1.5 | 1.0 | 0.15 | 8 | 16 | Ontology 20, Human checks 5, Pipeline 4, Linking 3 |\n| Ontology and sameness | 183,041 | 1.4 | 0.9 | 0.14 | 7 | 14 | Ontology 34, Pipeline 31, Linking 28, Human checks 19 |\n| Books, concepts and words | 181,884 | 1.4 | 0.9 | 0.13 | 7 | 14 | Ontology 33, Convergence 9, Parts 8, Linking 6 |\n| What goes under a link | 190,180 | 1.4 | 0.9 | 0.14 | 7 | 15 | Linking 7, Ontology 7, Machine inferences 5, Parts 4 |\n| Decomposition and the strength layer | 163,229 | 1.2 | 0.8 | 0.12 | 6 | 13 | Parts 44, Pipeline 29, Linking 21, Ontology 19 |\n| Sweeps, microtasks and their checks | 164,844 | 1.2 | 0.8 | 0.12 | 6 | 13 | Machine inferences 21, Human checks 19, Linking 11, Pipeline 8 |\n| Vision and alignment | 134,223 | 1.0 | 0.7 | 0.10 | 5 | 11 | Studies 21, Strategy 12, Convergence 6, Pipeline 4 |\n| Building the extraction pipeline | 128,101 | 0.9 | 0.6 | 0.09 | 5 | 10 | Pipeline 37, Ontology 7, Linking 4, Convergence 3 |\n| The site and its UX | 123,307 | 0.9 | 0.6 | 0.09 | 5 | 10 | Strategy 22, Studies 15, Human checks 7, Pipeline 6 |\n| The corpus graph's readers | 113,444 | 0.8 | 0.6 | 0.08 | 4 | 9 |  |\n| Checking one inference | 106,496 | 0.8 | 0.5 | 0.08 | 4 | 8 | Machine inferences 1, Human checks 1, Pipeline 1 |\n\n## What each area holds\n\n### Scales, transitions and judgment (290,086 tokens, 46 notes, 57 ledger rows)\n\nMajor transitions and evolvability, scales and time frames, legibility under power, what human judgment is for, depth and the convergence wager.\n\n- `docs/research/major-transitions-heredity-and-evolvability.md`\n- `specs/landing-redesign/constellation-map.md`\n- `docs/research/what-human-judgment-is-for.md`\n- `docs/research/legibility-under-power-red-team.md`\n- `docs/research/fractal-scales-and-temporal-frame.md`\n- `docs/research/lowering-the-cost.md`\n- `docs/research/convergence-wager-red-team.md`\n- `docs/research/structure-versus-scale.md`\n- `docs/research/threads-synthesis-and-gaps.md`\n- `docs/research/derivability-of-missing-considerations.md`\n- `docs/research/convictions-across-scales.md`\n- `docs/research/constellation-candidates.md`\n- `docs/depth.md`\n- `docs/research/curiosity-as-growth-fuel.md`\n- `docs/research/memetic-immune-system.md`\n- `docs/research/why-representations-converge-and-whether-minds-do.md`\n- `docs/research/the-harness-conviction.md`\n- `docs/research/incentives-analysis.md`\n- `docs/research/a-cognitive-ecology-and-the-terms-of-the-relation.md`\n- `docs/research/fractal-priors-for-success.md`\n- `docs/research/contingency-and-convergence-across-levels.md`\n- `docs/research/conviction-and-critique.md`\n- `docs/worldview-lenses.md`\n- `docs/research/complexity-transitions-and-why-now.md`\n- `docs/research/session29-the-derivability-arc-and-the-conservative-design.md`\n- `docs/analysis-and-attunement.md`\n- `docs/frontier.md`\n- `docs/research/assembly-theory-and-the-reuse-mechanism.md`\n- `docs/research/societal-integration-outlook.md`\n- `sources/chatgpt-literature-dump-2026-08.md`\n- `docs/research/cheap-to-add-slow-to-matter.md`\n- `docs/research/coupling-the-poles.md`\n- `docs/research/embeddings-tension-and-ai-slop.md`\n- `docs/research/universal-embedding-geometry-and-the-wager.md`\n- `docs/research/red-team-synthesis-2026-07.md`\n- `docs/research/nativism-thread-and-false-dissolution.md`\n- `docs/research/structuring-gradient-lineage.md`\n- `sources/nativism-thread-2020-marcus-dietterich-bach-george-pearl.md`\n- `docs/research/scaffolding-versus-difficulty.md`\n- `docs/research/kulturkapital-and-the-unscalable.md`\n- `docs/research/engagement-gradient-priors.md`\n- `docs/research/storytelling-and-the-story-layer.md`\n- `docs/research/reflection-and-the-graph.md`\n- `docs/research/curiosity-as-connection-zurn-bassett.md`\n- `docs/research/cyborg-manifesto-and-the-harness.md`\n- `specs/landing-redesign/design.md`\n\n### Adoption, democracy and strategy (267,585 tokens, 42 notes, 4 ledger rows)\n\nCollective intelligence and epistemic democracy, bridging arguments, adoption and single-player use, gamification, governance and financing, critiques.\n\n- `docs/conceptual-threads.md`\n- `docs/research/bridging-arguments.md`\n- `docs/research/execution-plan-clarification-first-roadmap.md`\n- `docs/research/governance-and-financing.md`\n- `docs/research/feed-algorithm-design.md`\n- `docs/research/single-player-utility.md`\n- `docs/research/session7-deep-review-and-strategic-assessment.md`\n- `docs/research/epistemic-gamification.md`\n- `docs/research/collective-intelligence-and-epistemic-democracy.md`\n- `docs/research/ai-augmented-cooperation-infrastructure.md`\n- `docs/research/adoption-problem.md`\n- `docs/research/sff-2026-and-fiscal-sponsorship-path.md`\n- `docs/technical-direction.md`\n- `docs/research/steelmanned-critiques.md`\n- `docs/research/polis-deep-dive.md`\n- `docs/research/cross-thread-synthesis.md`\n- `docs/academic-foundations.md`\n- `docs/research/argsbase-argument-web.md`\n- `docs/research/simplenote-archive-analysis.md`\n- `docs/research/deliberus-as-a-desktop-app.md`\n- `docs/history.md`\n- `docs/research/bmad-framework-analysis.md`\n- `docs/research/session10-empirical-collaboration-and-atomization-frontier.md`\n- `docs/research/kialo-deep-dive.md`\n- `docs/research/wiki-that-writes-itself-and-productive-friction.md`\n- `docs/research/habermas-machine.md`\n- `sources/chatgpt-research-thread-2026-08.md`\n- `docs/research/auth-patterns-deliberation-platforms.md`\n- `docs/research/safari-bookmarks-scan.md`\n- `docs/competitive-landscape.md`\n- `docs/bridging.md`\n- `docs/research/online-deliberation-pdf.md`\n- `docs/research/chat-logs-analysis.md`\n- `docs/research/carriers.md`\n- `docs/research/deliberation-io.md`\n- `docs/research/spec-session-reasoning.md`\n- `docs/research/voice-memo-emanuel-sofia.md`\n- `docs/research/consensus-path-forward.md`\n- `docs/community-and-outreach.md`\n- `docs/research/antithesis-simulation-pilot.md`\n- `docs/history-delibr-era.md`\n- `docs/research/delibrai-current-state.md`\n\n### Science, proof and the AI race (274,194 tokens, 41 notes, 40 ledger rows)\n\nThe literature as a data structure, Lean and proof machines, science infrastructure, the alignment red team and the coordination game.\n\n- `docs/research/tools-and-analogies-as-engines-of-discovery.md`\n- `docs/research/alignment-infrastructure-red-team.md`\n- `docs/research/the-literature-as-a-distributed-data-structure.md`\n- `docs/research/science-lineage-philosophy.md`\n- `docs/research/science-reasoning-infrastructure.md`\n- `docs/research/schmachtenberger-and-the-ai-race.md`\n- `docs/research/ai-risk-for-mathematicians-and-the-coordination-game.md`\n- `docs/research/the-literature-as-a-distributed-data-structure/report-data-structure-and-ground-truth-2026-11-04.md`\n- `docs/research/alien-proofs-and-the-library.md`\n- `docs/research/lean-deliberus-analogies.md`\n- `docs/research/lean4-proof-assistant-deep-dive.md`\n- `docs/research/fragile-checkers-and-the-verification-bottleneck.md`\n- `docs/research/the-literature-as-a-distributed-data-structure/report-tweet-and-ai-review-2026-11-04.md`\n- `docs/research/lean-social-system-research.md`\n- `sources/podcasts/night-science-083-mitchell-analogy-2026-02-16.md`\n- `docs/research/the-scrutiny-gap.md`\n- `sources/aipolicyperspectives-2026-10-28-tools-over-theories-griffin.md`\n- `docs/research/bend-and-deliberus.md`\n- `docs/research/bend-and-deliberus/bend2-status-report-2026-10-26.md`\n- `docs/research/four-cuts-of-the-ai-debate.md`\n- `docs/research/alignment-infrastructure-red-team/shared-assessments-as-coordination-devices-report-2026-11-02.md`\n- `docs/research/derivation-sciencepedia-and-the-logic-core.md`\n- `docs/research/bend-and-deliberus/bend-hvm-status-report-2026-09-29.md`\n- `docs/research/peer-review-and-the-reasoning-layer.md`\n- `docs/research/mapping-a-structured-position-on-ai-governance.md`\n- `docs/research/alignment-infrastructure-red-team/ablation-and-what-survives-report-2026-11-02.md`\n- `docs/research/tools-and-analogies-as-engines-of-discovery/analogy-in-science-sources-as-read-2026-11-05.md`\n- `docs/research/scientific-method-two-steps-and-deliberus.md`\n- `docs/research/grounded-critics-and-quarantined-imagination.md`\n- `docs/research/alignment-infrastructure-red-team/altman-ladder-and-monitorability-report-2026-11-02.md`\n- `docs/research/alignment-infrastructure-red-team/human-side-of-alignment-theory-and-evidence-report-2026-11-02.md`\n- `docs/research/tools-and-analogies-as-engines-of-discovery/krauss-and-the-instrument-first-tradition-sources-as-read-2026-11-05.md`\n- `docs/research/understanding-after-the-proof-machines.md`\n- `docs/research/ai-slop-and-the-reasoning-layer.md`\n- `docs/research/cognitive-commons-and-deliberus.md`\n- `docs/the-missing-layer.md`\n- `docs/research/formalized-fermat-and-the-oracle-boundary.md`\n- `docs/research/steadying-an-outside-judge.md`\n- `docs/research/the-disempowerment-objection.md`\n- `sources/referee-report-2026-08-structural-value-alignment.md`\n- `sources/README.md`\n\n### Priors, cases and how reasons add (270,016 tokens, 30 notes, 44 ledger rows)\n\nThe problem of the prior, reference classes, prediction markets, argument schemes, how independent reasons add, real cases.\n\n- `docs/research/starting-values-and-the-problem-of-the-prior.md`\n- `docs/research/priors-as-standing-work/reference-classes-found-2026-11-06.md`\n- `docs/research/testable-bets/hedges-vagueness-and-testability-literature.md`\n- `docs/research/testable-bets/prediction-markets-resolution-practice.md`\n- `docs/research/scheme-set-exhaustiveness.md`\n- `docs/research/how-independent-reasons-add.md`\n- `docs/research/priors-as-standing-work.md`\n- `docs/research/strength-calculus-literature/computational-argumentation.md`\n- `docs/research/saying-what-kind-a-claim-is.md`\n- `docs/research/walton-argument-schemes.md`\n- `docs/research/prediction-markets-argumentation.md`\n- `docs/research/the-number-in-the-world-and-the-repertoire.md`\n- `docs/research/reasons-and-cases.md`\n- `docs/research/reasons-and-cases/real-cases-dependent-instances.md`\n- `docs/research/ranking-reasoning-quality-without-bedrock.md`\n- `docs/inductive-reasoning-research.md`\n- `docs/research/listening-for-the-calculus-and-sturdy-microtasks.md`\n- `docs/research/how-independent-reasons-add/real-cases-with-known-outcomes.md`\n- `docs/research/reasons-and-cases/literature-weight-of-evidence-and-exchangeability.md`\n- `docs/research/how-independent-reasons-add/literature-pooling-and-dependence.md`\n- `docs/research/folded-routes-and-shared-premises/markets-and-experts-report-2026-10-23.md`\n- `docs/research/priors-as-standing-work/research-report-2026-10-24.md`\n- `docs/research/saying-what-kind-a-claim-is/research-report-2026-10-24.md`\n- `docs/research/how-independent-reasons-add/argumentation-builders-on-probability.md`\n- `docs/research/the-irit-harvest.md`\n- `docs/research/arguing-a-reference-class-filing-ux.md`\n- `docs/research/qbaf-gradual-semantics-research.md`\n- `docs/research/assumption-ranking.md`\n- `docs/research/how-independent-reasons-add/his-readings.md`\n- `docs/research/testable-bets/README.md`\n\n### What counts as evidence (229,508 tokens, 15 notes, 26 ledger rows)\n\nEvidence across law, intelligence, science, testimony and formal models; burden of proof.\n\n- `docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/law-intelligence-history-journalism-forensics.md`\n- `docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/testimony-experience-and-normative-evidence.md`\n- `docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/philosophy-of-evidence.md`\n- `docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/grading-evidence-in-science-and-policy.md`\n- `docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/formal-and-computational-models-of-evidence.md`\n- `docs/research/strength-calculus-literature/bayesian-and-informal-logic.md`\n- `docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence.md`\n- `docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/corpus-map-research-docs.md`\n- `docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/corpus-map-founder-voice.md`\n- `docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/corpus-map-code.md`\n- `docs/research/burden-of-proof-and-priors.md`\n- `docs/research/burden-of-proof-and-priors/psychology-and-cases-report.md`\n- `docs/research/burden-of-proof-and-priors/theory-report.md`\n- `docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/research-briefing.md`\n- `docs/research/what-counts-as-evidence/README.md`\n\n### The project reading itself (238,159 tokens, 29 notes, 60 ledger rows)\n\nThe canon distillation pass, signposts for the whole project, how the project evolved, the kind of mistake we make.\n\n- `docs/research/the-canon-distillation-pass/topic-index-trim-proposals.md`\n- `docs/research/the-canon-distillation-pass.md`\n- `docs/research/split-review-and-the-founders-intentions.md`\n- `docs/research/the-kind-of-mistake-we-make.md`\n- `docs/research/flywheels-in-building-deliberus/literature-report-2026-10-22.md`\n- `docs/research/what-deliberus-is-for.md`\n- `docs/research/catching-a-proposal-made-unnecessary/report-formal-methods.md`\n- `docs/research/signposts-for-the-whole-project.md`\n- `docs/research/how-the-project-evolved-read-from-the-record.md`\n- `docs/research/session27-the-canon-pass-and-the-corpus-blind-spot.md`\n- `docs/research/flywheels-in-building-deliberus.md`\n- `docs/research/outside-checks/README.md`\n- `docs/research/catching-a-proposal-made-unnecessary.md`\n- `docs/research/the-feed-reconsidered.md`\n- `docs/research/the-ratification-record-and-the-triage-feed.md`\n- `docs/research/session36-the-keeper-and-the-order-of-asking.md`\n- `docs/research/the-tidying-line.md`\n- `docs/research/session39-what-the-graph-stopped-claiming.md`\n- `docs/research/session21-single-surface-correction-and-the-modality-objection.md`\n- `docs/research/unweighed-answers-two-months.md`\n- `docs/research/session34-open-loops-and-unweighed-answers.md`\n- `docs/research/what-the-walkthroughs-and-the-reviews-are-for.md`\n- `docs/research/what-confirmed-means.md`\n- `docs/research/session35-the-verification-night.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/repairs-made.md`\n- `docs/research/session28-the-harness-arc-and-the-source-intake.md`\n- `docs/research/flywheels-in-building-deliberus/checkins.md`\n- `docs/research/catching-a-proposal-made-unnecessary/cases-negatives/BD29.md`\n- `docs/research/catching-a-proposal-made-unnecessary/cases/S2.md`\n\n### Maps, the graph and the early group (214,938 tokens, 27 notes, 33 ledger rows)\n\nGraph visualization, folding and zoom, the map's design, the 2011 to 2017 group, early prototypes.\n\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/README.md`\n- `specs/map-view/design.md`\n- `docs/research/graph-visualization.md`\n- `docs/research/folding-joining-and-zoom.md`\n- `docs/research/what-the-group-held-2011-2017.md`\n- `docs/research/what-he-held-in-the-group-2011-2013.md`\n- `docs/research/folded-routes-and-shared-premises.md`\n- `docs/research/practices-for-interconnected-research.md`\n- `docs/research/crdt-collaborative-graphs.md`\n- `docs/research/meteor-prototype-analysis.md`\n- `docs/research/how-a-map-is-cut-and-what-it-shows.md`\n- `docs/research/an-outside-reading-of-the-thesis.md`\n- `docs/research/falkordb-cypher-coverage.md`\n- `docs/sketches.md`\n- `docs/research/folded-routes-and-shared-premises/folding-paths-report-2026-10-23.md`\n- `docs/open-problems.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/haiku-5-5-for-the-filling.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/graphrag-cost-benefit.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/finding-unwritten-connections-as-a-helper-read-it.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/graph-retrieval-measured-gotchas-as-a-helper-read-it.md`\n- `docs/research/legacy-object-model-harvest.md`\n- `docs/research/practices-for-interconnected-research/structure-peers-as-a-helper-read-them.md`\n- `docs/research/practices-for-interconnected-research/practice-peers-as-a-helper-read-them.md`\n- `docs/research/interface-words-audit.md`\n- `docs/object-model.md`\n- `docs/research/catching-a-proposal-made-unnecessary/cases-negatives/AX4.md`\n- `docs/research/catching-a-proposal-made-unnecessary/cases/AX10.md`\n\n### Strength and relevance (215,515 tokens, 17 notes, 52 ledger rows)\n\nThe reasons channel, strength rulings, relevance and its two factors, parts and reasons, the unwritten step.\n\n- `docs/research/retrofitting-the-reasons-channel.md`\n- `docs/research/philosophy-of-the-unwritten-step/what-each-lookup-returned.md`\n- `docs/research/the-squirrel-and-the-strength-calculus/strength-rulings-and-code-as-read-2026-10-08.md`\n- `docs/research/relevance-in-the-corpus-sweep.md`\n- `docs/research/where-a-shared-doubt-sits.md`\n- `docs/research/philosophy-of-the-unwritten-step.md`\n- `docs/research/what-a-link-rests-on/outside-reading-argumentation-theory.md`\n- `docs/research/relevance-and-the-two-factors.md`\n- `docs/research/what-relevance-is.md`\n- `docs/research/a-part-and-a-reason.md`\n- `docs/research/claim-parts-and-inferential-reasons-2026-10-14.md`\n- `docs/research/the-squirrel-and-the-strength-calculus.md`\n- `docs/research/what-the-number-on-a-claim-means.md`\n- `docs/research/session41-when-a-reason-fails.md`\n- `docs/research/what-a-link-strength-means.md`\n- `docs/research/session40-two-factors-and-a-day-of-rulings.md`\n- `docs/research/weighing-answers-and-the-badge-threshold.md`\n\n### Values and convergence (209,172 tokens, 34 notes, 56 ledger rows)\n\nMoral convergence, decomposing value, normative reasoning, lenses, polarization and deliberation evidence.\n\n- `docs/research/what-if-and-lenses/outside-reading-psychology.md`\n- `docs/research/what-if-and-lenses/outside-reading-formal.md`\n- `docs/research/value-weighting-decomposition.md`\n- `docs/convergence.md`\n- `docs/research/decomposing-value.md`\n- `docs/research/dogfood-run-7-swedish-election-structured-vs-unstructured.md`\n- `docs/research/good-hearts-and-permissivism.md`\n- `docs/research/moral-convergence-metaethics-and-psychology.md`\n- `docs/research/normative-reasoning.md`\n- `docs/research/philosophical-foundations-stress-test.md`\n- `docs/research/causes-of-belief-and-the-three-minds.md`\n- `docs/research/what-if-and-lenses.md`\n- `docs/research/trust-economics-and-false-polarization.md`\n- `docs/research/empirical-deliberation-convergence-evidence.md`\n- `docs/research/cognitive-bias-codex-and-human-contribution.md`\n- `docs/research/does-descending-change-the-descender.md`\n- `docs/research/convergence-thread-corpus-map.md`\n- `docs/research/election-2026-bloc-debate-cluster.md`\n- `docs/research/convergence-wager-typed-residues-synthesis.md`\n- `docs/research/the-group-premise-evidence.md`\n- `docs/research/fractal-priors-for-convergence.md`\n- `docs/research/deeper-democracy-and-the-oscillation-cost.md`\n- `docs/research/deep-descent-experiment/pain-badness-descent.md`\n- `docs/research/the-post-that-states-the-problem-from-inside.md`\n- `docs/research/deep-descent-experiment/white-lies-descent.md`\n- `docs/research/heylighen-value-complexity-and-deliberus.md`\n- `docs/research/deep-descent-experiment.md`\n- `docs/research/live-test-simulation-vardforsakringen.md`\n- `docs/research/weighing-eval/text-mp-oped.md`\n- `docs/research/catching-a-proposal-made-unnecessary/cases-negatives/BD27.md`\n- `docs/research/catching-a-proposal-made-unnecessary/cases-negatives/BD28.md`\n- `docs/research/weighing-eval/text-s-polemic.md`\n- `docs/research/catching-a-proposal-made-unnecessary/cases/AU8.md`\n- `docs/research/catching-a-proposal-made-unnecessary/cases/I13.md`\n\n### Rules, analogy and minds (200,431 tokens, 31 notes, 53 ledger rows)\n\nWhat a rule rests on, analogy and its engines, normic rules, cases and generalizations, the machine-consciousness debate.\n\n- `docs/research/what-a-rule-rests-on.md`\n- `docs/research/cases-and-generalizations-from-both-ends.md`\n- `docs/research/overlaps-and-analogy.md`\n- `docs/research/three-minds-and-the-leap.md`\n- `docs/research/the-analogy-daemon.md`\n- `docs/research/normic-rules-normative-reasons-and-trying-rules-out.md`\n- `docs/research/what-a-rule-rests-on/cognitive-science-sources-as-read-2026-10-08.md`\n- `docs/research/mapping-the-machine-consciousness-debate.md`\n- `docs/research/what-a-rule-rests-on/philosophy-sources-as-read-2026-10-08.md`\n- `docs/research/what-a-case-counts-for.md`\n- `docs/research/what-a-rule-rests-on/corpus-as-read-2026-10-08.md`\n- `docs/research/theorists-on-normic-rules-exceptions-numbers-and-many-minds.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/likeness-seen-from-outside.md`\n- `docs/research/a-tree-per-claim.md`\n- `docs/research/perceiving-possibility-and-the-analogy-organ.md`\n- `docs/research/cases-and-generalizations-from-both-ends/literature-report-2026-11-06.md`\n- `docs/research/the-chain-inside-a-link/sentient-silicon-pair-through-the-pipeline.md`\n- `docs/research/what-a-case-counts-for/literature-as-read.md`\n- `docs/research/what-a-rule-rests-on/older-corpus-bearings-likeness-shapes-and-bottoms-2026-10-08.md`\n- `docs/research/what-a-rule-rests-on/older-corpus-bearings-people-and-agreement-2026-10-08.md`\n- `docs/research/what-a-rule-rests-on/older-corpus-bearings-strength-and-machine-work-2026-10-08.md`\n- `docs/research/retrieval-instruments-beyond-cosine.md`\n- `docs/research/what-a-rule-rests-on/cases-and-principles-sources-as-read-2026-10-08.md`\n- `docs/research/what-a-rule-rests-on/likeness-and-worldview-sources-as-read-2026-10-08.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/what-a-move-is.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/what-research-says-about-finding-far-analogies.md`\n- `docs/research/careful-and-broad-minds.md`\n- `docs/research/grounding/scope.read.md`\n- `docs/research/grounding/keeper.pair.md`\n- `docs/research/catching-a-proposal-made-unnecessary/cases-negatives/AF1.md`\n- `docs/research/catching-a-proposal-made-unnecessary/cases/AF1.md`\n\n### Ontology and sameness (183,041 tokens, 33 notes, 20 ledger rows)\n\nWhat belongs in the ontology, when two claims are the same, merge and split, the residual error taxonomy, agents in the graph.\n\n- `docs/research/what-belongs-in-the-ontology.md`\n- `docs/research/imagined-graph-extraction-and-checkable-reasoning-2026-10-28.md`\n- `docs/research/truth-graph-evidence-system.md`\n- `docs/research/synthesis-build-plan.md`\n- `docs/research/the-residual-error-taxonomy.md`\n- `docs/research/soft-canonical-clustering-and-reversible-merge-semantics.md`\n- `docs/research/agents-as-a-consumer-class.md`\n- `docs/research/parity-and-the-zone-interior.md`\n- `docs/research/weighing-scheme-and-terminus-classifier-design.md`\n- `docs/research/the-reuse-flywheel-prior.md`\n- `docs/research/sameness-merge-and-split-across-fields.md`\n- `docs/research/the-agent-population-and-what-checking-is-up-against.md`\n- `docs/research/long-form-sources-and-meta-analysis-weighing.md`\n- `docs/research/saturation-and-the-long-tail.md`\n- `docs/research/world-completeness-and-its-relatives.md`\n- `docs/research/session19-decomposition-corrections-and-the-ontology-turn.md`\n- `docs/research/world-models-and-the-ontology-revival.md`\n- `docs/research/session33-the-horizon-vocabulary.md`\n- `docs/research/graph-daemons-design-space.md`\n- `docs/research/kartpaus-auto-enrichment-design.md`\n- `docs/research/weighing-detection-semantic-tier.md`\n- `docs/research/taxonomy-gaps-and-the-closed-enum.md`\n- `docs/research/active-inference-context-acquisition-and-deliberus.md`\n- `docs/research/drowning-in-claims.md`\n- `docs/research/latent-scaffolding-and-the-type-token-split.md`\n- `docs/research/supersession-and-bitemporal-lifecycles.md`\n- `docs/research/asteroid-and-feeling-around-sources.md`\n- `docs/research/agent-readable-graph-architecture.md`\n- `docs/research/wild-weighing-dialects-and-the-question-set.md`\n- `docs/research/what-agent-memory-research-says-about-agent-surfaces.md`\n- `docs/research/nesy-rag-note.md`\n- `docs/research/weighing-eval/ground-truth-public.md`\n- `docs/research/catching-a-proposal-made-unnecessary/cases/P13.md`\n\n### Books, concepts and words (181,884 tokens, 20 notes, 16 ledger rows)\n\nTwelve books read against Deliberus, the Tractatus, podcast sources, the concept layer, motte and bailey.\n\n- `docs/research/twelve-books-read-against-deliberus.md`\n- `sources/podcasts/thinkroom-ringertz-norlin-strukturkapital.md`\n- `docs/research/the-tractatus-and-deliberus.md`\n- `sources/podcasts/overthink-062-curiosity-zurn-bassett.md`\n- `sources/podcasts/overthink-164-haraway-cyborg-manifesto.md`\n- `sources/podcasts/overthink-182-reflection.md`\n- `docs/research/core-periphery-and-the-concept-layer.md`\n- `docs/research/twelve-books-in-plain-words.md`\n- `docs/research/prime-real-estate-words.md`\n- `sources/podcasts/rationality-rules-jubilee-motte-and-bailey-2025-06-28.md`\n- `docs/research/the-motte-and-the-periphery.md`\n- `sources/podcasts/rationality-rules-7-argument-tactics-2025-05-31.md`\n- `docs/research/four-books-the-corpus-had-not-read.md`\n- `docs/research/claim-sameness-philosophical-readings.md`\n- `docs/research/the-load-bearing-unsaid.md`\n- `docs/research/univocity-and-the-concept-layer.md`\n- `docs/research/a-cut-through-a-concept-is-an-argument.md`\n- `docs/research/attunement-words-and-the-concept-layer.md`\n- `docs/research/semantic-disambiguation-and-concept-tracking.md`\n- `docs/research/definitions-as-alignment-tests.md`\n\n### What goes under a link (190,180 tokens, 17 notes, 58 ledger rows)\n\nThe chain inside a link, writing out the unwritten, what a link rests on, how far a premise is from its claim.\n\n- `docs/research/one-challenge-one-home.md`\n- `docs/research/session49-what-goes-under-a-link.md`\n- `docs/research/the-chain-inside-a-link.md`\n- `docs/research/writing-out-the-unwritten.md`\n- `docs/research/the-chain-inside-a-link/ten-links-written-to-the-floor.md`\n- `docs/research/a-sentence-as-a-pointer-into-a-landscape.md`\n- `docs/research/store-the-uses-read-the-meaning.md`\n- `docs/research/codex-review-19-october-read-back.md`\n- `docs/research/points-of-entry-review.md`\n- `docs/research/claim-or-system.md`\n- `docs/research/what-a-link-rests-on.md`\n- `docs/graph-properties.md`\n- `docs/research/how-far-a-premise-is-from-its-claim.md`\n- `docs/research/the-yellow-link.md`\n- `docs/research/codex-review-19-october-second-reading-2026-10-20.md`\n- `docs/research/claims-and-code-one-loop.md`\n- `docs/research/grounding/claim.reading.md`\n\n### Decomposition and the strength layer (163,229 tokens, 25 notes, 34 ledger rows)\n\nDecomposition axes, microtasks, Jev's judging, weakest-link arithmetic, accrual and the overlap check.\n\n- `docs/research/weakest-link-arithmetic-and-the-merge-hunch.md`\n- `docs/research/microtasks-in-broad-daylight.md`\n- `docs/research/jev-and-the-judgement-layer.md`\n- `docs/research/auto-connect-upgrade.md`\n- `docs/research/self-similar-decomposition-and-claim-ontology.md`\n- `docs/research/dogfood-run-6-israel-palestine-cross-domain.md`\n- `docs/research/pollock-against-accrual-and-the-overlap-check.md`\n- `docs/research/scheme-bounded-decomposition-and-evidence-as-subgraph.md`\n- `docs/research/resonance-db-and-negation.md`\n- `docs/research/decomposition-axes.md`\n- `docs/research/strength-layer-audit.md`\n- `docs/research/synthetic-stress-suite-and-ontology-reflection.md`\n- `docs/research/the-jhu-decomposition-line.md`\n- `docs/research/evidence-division-and-the-foundation.md`\n- `docs/research/session20-the-strength-layer-and-the-unspecified-middle.md`\n- `docs/research/the-parts-review.md`\n- `docs/research/what-the-necessary-default-changes.md`\n- `docs/research/support-semantics-and-the-conjunction-problem.md`\n- `docs/research/the-remaining-case-for-the-stance-guard.md`\n- `docs/research/cross-source-premise-run.md`\n- `docs/research/exact-terms-audit.md`\n- `docs/research/reading-the-text-itself.md`\n- `docs/research/slicing-stability-first-run.md`\n- `docs/research/linked-convergent-and-what-we-are-actually-asking.md`\n- `docs/research/resonance-db-and-negation/table.md`\n\n### Sweeps, microtasks and their checks (164,844 tokens, 15 notes, 51 ledger rows)\n\nProving a pass reliable, choosing a model, machine work as a standing property, checks on machines and people.\n\n- `docs/research/quality-control-for-deeper-steps.md`\n- `docs/research/pass-quality-and-the-choice-of-model.md`\n- `docs/research/whose-tokens-pay-for-mapping.md`\n- `docs/research/machine-work-as-a-standing-property.md`\n- `docs/research/proving-a-pass-reliable.md`\n- `docs/research/checks-on-machines-and-people.md`\n- `docs/research/the-evals-loop-and-our-machine-passes.md`\n- `docs/research/earning-the-right-to-write.md`\n- `docs/research/what-a-record-linkage-project-teaches-deliberus.md`\n- `docs/research/storing-the-record-of-machine-judgments.md`\n- `docs/research/quality-control-for-deeper-steps/corpus-bearings-people-and-what-checks-cannot-see-as-a-reader-returned-it.md`\n- `docs/research/quality-control-for-deeper-steps/corpus-bearings-depth-chains-and-error-as-a-reader-returned-it.md`\n- `docs/research/quality-control-for-deeper-steps/corpus-bearings-how-the-small-tasks-are-checked-as-a-reader-returned-it.md`\n- `docs/research/quality-control-for-deeper-steps/the-three-briefs.md`\n- `docs/research/citations-in-the-passes.md`\n\n### Vision and alignment (134,223 tokens, 15 notes, 27 ledger rows)\n\nThe vision, Deliberus as alignment infrastructure, non-zero-sum cooperation, the civilizational vision.\n\n- `docs/vision.md`\n- `docs/research/shared-sensemaking-what-deliberus-holds-and-owes.md`\n- `docs/research/deliberus-as-alignment-infrastructure.md`\n- `docs/research/non-zero-sum-economics-and-civilizational-cooperation.md`\n- `docs/research/david-deutsch-deep-research-non-zero-sum-economics.md`\n- `docs/research/non-zero-sum-game-theory-and-cooperation-economics.md`\n- `docs/research/zizek-schmachtenberger-connections.md`\n- `docs/research/ai-safety-and-tao-augmentation-research.md`\n- `docs/civilizational-vision.md`\n- `docs/research/session8-landing-page-and-civilizational-vision.md`\n- `docs/research/bengio-safety-from-honesty-and-deliberus.md`\n- `docs/research/wright-god-test-noosphere-and-deliberus.md`\n- `docs/research/david-deutsch-beginning-of-infinity-and-deliberus.md`\n- `docs/research/forecasting-room-at-the-top-and-deliberus.md`\n- `docs/research/80000-hours-ai-decision-making.md`\n\n### Building the extraction pipeline (128,101 tokens, 19 notes, 3 ledger rows)\n\nArchitecture, extraction design and experiments, deploys and outages, the dogfood runs.\n\n- `docs/research/codex-session-20260403.md`\n- `docs/architecture-reference.md`\n- `docs/research/extraction-improvement-research.md`\n- `docs/research/claude-code-as-extraction-engine.md`\n- `docs/research/session13-notification-snr-and-extraction-outage-rca.md`\n- `docs/research/extraction-pipeline-design.md`\n- `docs/research/llm-speed-optimization.md`\n- `docs/research/dogfood-run-1-friction-log.md`\n- `docs/research/session11-merian-deploy-recovery-and-secrets-drift.md`\n- `docs/research/frontier-extraction-experiment.md`\n- `docs/research/first-pipeline-run-analysis.md`\n- `docs/research/dogfood-run-4-agent-surface.md`\n- `docs/research/dogfood-run-2-orthogonal-experiments.md`\n- `docs/research/temporal-extraction-architecture.md`\n- `docs/research/extraction-virtual-run.md`\n- `docs/extraction-pipeline.md`\n- `docs/research/session12-production-recovery-and-secrets-fix.md`\n- `docs/research/anthropic-harness-extraction-analysis.md`\n- `docs/anamnesis_recovery_2026_04_30/SUBMIT_INSTRUCTIONS.md`\n\n### The site and its UX (123,307 tokens, 23 notes, 4 ledger rows)\n\nUX principles, mobile, progressive disclosure, game feel, the design guide, the live election test.\n\n- `docs/ux-principles.md`\n- `docs/research/live-election-test-design.md`\n- `docs/research/mobile-argument-ux.md`\n- `docs/research/site-declutter-directions.md`\n- `docs/research/progressive-disclosure.md`\n- `docs/research/blobs-community-sandboxes-and-the-advice-process.md`\n- `docs/research/islands-of-coherence.md`\n- `docs/research/game-feel-and-the-first-screen.md`\n- `docs/research/interaction-modalities-and-the-pointing-test.md`\n- `docs/design-guide.md`\n- `specs/landing-redesign/tasks.md`\n- `docs/research/disambiguation-ux-and-voice-first-contribution.md`\n- `docs/research/unbuilt-features-research-mar31.md`\n- `docs/research/session34-the-unconference-arc.md`\n- `docs/research/game-feel-mechanics-sketchbook.md`\n- `docs/research/combinatorial-mvp-reasoning.md`\n- `docs/design/dialectic_dark_1/DESIGN.md`\n- `docs/design/dialectic_dark_2/DESIGN.md`\n- `specs/landing-redesign/requirements.md`\n- `specs/landing-redesign/invitation-copy.md`\n- `docs/design/dialectic_dark_3/DESIGN.md`\n- `docs/research/n-of-1-uplift-protocols.md`\n- `docs/research/second-opinion-mvp-strategy.md`\n\n### The corpus graph's readers (113,444 tokens, 12 notes, 38 ledger rows)\n\nWhat the readers found beyond pairs of notes, the briefs they read, the decision clusters.\n\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/what-readers-said-that-is-no-pair-of-notes.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/what-the-readers-noticed-beyond-their-forms.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/reading-for-every-kind-of-insight.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/decision-clusters.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/reading-for-insight/kinds-of-insight-and-judging-as-a-helper-read-it.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/reading-for-insight/whole-corpus-insight-as-a-helper-read-it.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/dissonance-reading-brief.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/kinship-reading-brief.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/model-tests/reader-brief.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/reader_brief.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/open-reading-brief.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/reader_brief_part_two_the_judging_direction.md`\n\n### Checking one inference (106,496 tokens, 14 notes, 12 ledger rows)\n\nOne inference per link, methods and engines for checking an inference, parsers to logic, finding inconsistencies.\n\n- `docs/research/one-inference-per-link.md`\n- `docs/research/what-a-link-rests-on/outside-reading-machines-naming-premises.md`\n- `docs/research/writing-out-the-unwritten/outside-reading-dependable-small-tasks.md`\n- `docs/research/writing-out-the-unwritten/outside-reading-explication-with-checks.md`\n- `docs/research/one-inference-per-link/report-datasets-and-historical-cases.md`\n- `docs/research/tools-for-checking-inferences.md`\n- `docs/research/catching-a-proposal-made-unnecessary/report-llm-methods.md`\n- `docs/research/one-inference-per-link/report-methods-for-one-inference.md`\n- `docs/research/tools-for-checking-inferences/report-engines-per-kind.md`\n- `docs/research/one-inference-per-link/report-what-is-hard-per-kind.md`\n- `docs/research/tools-for-checking-inferences/report-harness-design.md`\n- `docs/research/proving-pass-reliability/literature-report-2026-09-29.md`\n- `docs/research/tools-for-checking-inferences/report-parsers-to-logic.md`\n- `docs/research/corpus-graph/reading-for-insight/finding-inconsistencies-as-a-helper-read-it.md`\n\n## Left out\n\n- listening pieces retell notes for walks: 40 notes\n- readers' returns; what they found is in found.jsonl: 54 notes\n- generated cards: 5 notes\n- this list of areas: 1 notes\n"}